felix pie

phredmojo · 03-07-2008, 10:22 PM

how good is he? i don't pay too much attention to prospects outside of seattle. how good is he for a long term keeper money league with minor leaguers also. i've been offered pie, dioner navaro and andy marte for jorge posada. it would weaken my catchers to johjima and navarro.

645 · 03-08-2008, 03:15 AM

Alright then, First the down side. 1) Going from Posada to Johjima you will be giving up say about 5 Home Runs, 15 RBI's and maybe 20 Runs and 2) Pie may still be a season away from making a big fantasy impact.

So although Posada value is in decline and there isn't keeper value left in him but it will be 2009 before you start to get anything out of this deal.

But if you think you will finish out of the Money this year or if you are willing to risk finishing out of the money. Not to say you will but if you are willing.....

Well, Pie is worth it and I would take that deal. Just understand You are going to have to wait to get any value out of anyone of those players.

phredmojo · 03-09-2008, 01:00 AM

decided to take it, but changed the deal to pie, navarro and matt antonelli instead of marte. antonelli has to be able to post better then a .300 obp next year then my current 2b jose lopez lol

03-07-2008, 10:22 PM	#1 (permalink)
phredmojo Member Join Date: Dec 2006 Location: bellingham, wa Posts: 88	felix pie how good is he? i don't pay too much attention to prospects outside of seattle. how good is he for a long term keeper money league with minor leaguers also. i've been offered pie, dioner navaro and andy marte for jorge posada. it would weaken my catchers to johjima and navarro.

03-08-2008, 03:15 AM	#2 (permalink)
645 Moderator Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Milwaukee Posts: 5,987	Alright then, First the down side. 1) Going from Posada to Johjima you will be giving up say about 5 Home Runs, 15 RBI's and maybe 20 Runs and 2) Pie may still be a season away from making a big fantasy impact. So although Posada value is in decline and there isn't keeper value left in him but it will be 2009 before you start to get anything out of this deal. But if you think you will finish out of the Money this year or if you are willing to risk finishing out of the money. Not to say you will but if you are willing..... Well, Pie is worth it and I would take that deal. Just understand You are going to have to wait to get any value out of anyone of those players.

03-09-2008, 01:00 AM	#3 (permalink)
phredmojo Member Join Date: Dec 2006 Location: bellingham, wa Posts: 88	decided to take it, but changed the deal to pie, navarro and matt antonelli instead of marte. antonelli has to be able to post better then a .300 obp next year then my current 2b jose lopez lol