Quote:
Originally Posted by TylerDurden
When you have two players with similar stats at similar positions in similar offensive systems, but one came before the other, defined that position, had already been snubbed by the HOF in years past and played on four Super Bowl teams to the other's zero, the edge goes to that guy.
And if I recall correctly, Carter wasn't the best lockerroom presence on many of those Vikings teams.
Carter gets in, but not before Monk.
|
First of all, Their numbers are not that similar...Carter is ahead in most categories over Monk.
Secondly, since when did Art Monk define or redefine the WR position?
When you talk about a player defining or redifining a position, it must be a player who has totally done things at the position that no one else has ever done...SUCH AS LAWRENCE TAYLOR AT OLB! Monk never did anything that set him apart from other receivers in his era......Jerry Rice would be the example for the WR position....not Monk!
