I agree with your ranking, I just don't think the omissions on the Western side are quite as egregious (given limited availability of spots) as the ones in the East. While you're right that Davis and Wiliams are better than Nash this year, it's not as though Nash isn't All-Star caliber.
When it comes to the Eastern team, Hamilton and Johnson simply don't deserve to be All-Stars this year. They've having ho-hum decent seasons.
Watch some Magic and Raptors games and I think you'll agree with me that Turkoglu and Calderon are clearly more deserving than Hamilton and Johnson. After Dwight Howard, Turkoglu is Orlando's MVP. And I think Calderon has been the best point guard in the Eastern Conference this year, even ahead of Kidd and Billups.
|